We're asked for Best Buy recommendations much more often than Best Wine advice. So here are our Top Ten white and red bargains.
Ranking Rules
Only wines rated 80 or higher by my panel may enter.
Only two entries per category are permitted. That is, only two Chiantis, only two Merlots, etc. may enter.
All wines are current releases. The whites are from 1998 and 1999, the reds 1997 and 1998.
The rating divided by the price tells us how big a bargain
we have, our Best Buy Index The higher the
index, the more bang for the buck.
Since many enthusiasts like only red or only white, we provide
a Top Ten for each. The biggest bargain is
listed last. Here we go!
White & Sparkling
Name
Price
The Winery...Etc.
10th
Pinot Gris
$10
Duck Pond, Willamette Valley, Oregon
9th
Gewürztraminer
$8
Fetzer, California
8th
Gewürztraminer
$8
Meridian, Santa Barbara County, California,
(pictured)
7th
Late Harvest Riesling
$9
Hogue, Columbia Valley, Washington
6th
Riesling
$9
Jekel, Monterey County, California
5th
Sauvignon Blanc
$7
Tarapaca (Beringer), Maipo Valley, Chile
4th
Sparkler
$8
Barefoot Bubbly, California
3rd
Chardonnay
$7
Etchart, Mendoza, Argentina
2nd
Chardonnay
$6
Riverfort (Beringer), Pays d'Oc, France
1st
Torrontes
$6
Santa Julia, Mendoza, Argentina
Reds
Name
Price
The Winery...Etc.
10th
Black Muscat
$12
Shenandoah, Amador County, (dessert) California
9th
Pinot Noir
$7
Monterey Vineyard, Central Coast, California
8th
Malbec
$7
Ecthart, Mendoza, Argentina
7th
Shiraz (Syrah)
$8
McPherson, South Eastern Australia
6th
Cabernet Sauvignon
$7
Glen Ellen Reserve, California
5th
Malbec
$8
Santa Julia, Mendoza, Argentina
4th
Cabernet Sauvignon
$7
Monterey Vineyard, Monterey County, California
3rd
Merlot
$10
Farallon (Sebastiani), North Coast, California
2nd
Zinfandel
$9
Ironstone, Sierra Foothills, California
1st
Shiraz (Syrah)
$9
Carramar (Casella Wines), South Eastern
Australia
Comments
Non-California whites won six out of ten places, including
the top three spots. Their reds won only four of the ten
places, and only one of the top three.
Lots of good types didn't get in because there are very
few in this price range. Missing in action Viognier, Sangiovese,
Meritage whites and reds, etc.
Argentina topped the no-Cals, with an 8th, 5th, 3rd and
a 1st.